View ICR - OIRA Conclusion



2040-0257 200705-2040-002
Historical Active 200401-2040-001
EPA/OW 2060.03
Cooling Water Intake Structures Phase II Existing Facility (Renewal)
Extension without change of a currently approved collection   No
Regular
Approved without change 08/13/2007
05/29/2007
OMB is aware that major portions of the final rule containing the information collection requirements covered by this ICR have been remanded by the US 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals, and that the remaining portions of the rule have been stayed by EPA pending a new rule making to address the remanded portions. In the meantime, compliance with 316(b) permitting requirements for cooling water intake structures at existing large power plants will be determined on a best professional judgment (BPJ) basis by the permit writer, rather than in accordance with the national performance standards and procedures that were established in the remanded/stayed rule. While noting that the bulk of the work involved in preparing this ICR was conducted before the 2nd Circuit remand, EPA sserts that the types of information covered in this ICR reflecting the requirements of the rule are the same types of information that may need to be collected in the context of BPJ permitting decisions, although there will be more site-specific variability in the quantity and content of information collected under the BPJ approach. OMB finds this assertion reasonable. EPA further asserts that it would be difficult and an unproductive use of resources to try to estimate the exact information that will be collected and the burden that will be involved in providing this information under the interim BPJ permitting approach, but that this burden will almost certainly be less than what is requested to be authorized in this ICR, since many types of information covered by the ICR will be collected infrequently or not at all (eg, cost-cost and cost-benefit demonstrations, technology installation and operation plans). OMB also finds this assertion reasonable. Specifically, OMB agrees that the burden estimated in this ICR is likely to represent an upper bound on the burden that will be incurred by the public in complying with BPJ based permitting requirements for cooling water intake structures at large existing power plants over the next three years. Therefore, OMB is approving this ICR as submitted to provide interim authorization for the collection of information udner the BPJ permitting approach while EPA conducts a new rule making to respond to the Court remand. However, OMB expects that EPA will submit a revised ICR with the proposed and final rules that reflects the specific requirements in the new rule, including an appropriate and detailed estimate of burden. That ICR will replace this one when the new rule is promulgated.
  Inventory as of this Action Requested Previously Approved
08/31/2010 36 Months From Approved 08/31/2007
4,469 0 2,699
1,240,599 0 1,700,392
14,963,845 0 20,999,000